100% of your profit comes from existing customers - Alex Raymond | AMplify


Episode #303

​
​Customer Success is Dead, Meet the Growth Department

Hi Reader,

73% of B2B revenue comes from existing customers every year. That's Forrester's number, and it's been true for a long time. But when Alex Raymond walked me through the math on this week's episode, the part that stopped me wasn't the 73. It was the 100.

100% of your profits come from existing customers. Every dollar. Most new business is a cost center for the first 12–24 months — you're paying to acquire, onboard, and stabilize the account before it contributes anything back. The profit line only turns on once the customer renews.

Now look at how most SaaS companies actually fund the two teams. Sales gets 3x to 4x the headcount, the tooling, the kickoffs, the training budget. Post-sales gets what's left over. Then leadership asks why NRR is flat and valuation is down.

It's not a mystery. You're under-resourcing the team that generates 100% of your profit.
​
​What to do with this?

  • Run the ratio this quarter: total spend on new-logo acquisition vs. total spend on the existing base. If it's worse than 3:1 or 4:1, you have a resourcing problem, not a performance problem.
  • Before the next planning cycle, put one number in front of your CFO: cost to acquire one new dollar of ARR vs. cost to retain one existing dollar. Let the gap do the arguing.
  • If your CRO only owns the 27%, they’re not a CRO. They’re a VP of Sales with a fancy title.

This week's episode

E303 | Customer Success Is Dead. Meet the Growth Department.

Alex Raymond has spent years in account management, first as founder of Kapta, now running AMplify and author of The Growth Department. We got into why CS and AM are stuck in an identity crisis, and the specific org, comp, and language changes that pull them out of it.

Here’s what stood out:

  1. The resource allocation problem no one talks about — 73% of revenue, a fraction of the funding — [27:02]​
  2. The language shift that changes how CS is valued (“book of 30 customers” vs. “book of $3M”) — [29:45]​
  3. Why a true CRO should own 100% of revenue, not 27% — [08:09]​
  4. NRR as a North Star: the metric that kills the sales vs. CS cold war — [12:42]​
  5. Why over-indexing on relationship is how you get the “it’s been a pleasure, but we’re going in another direction” email — [23:05]​
  6. Why the 360-degree AE idea has no legs — hunters and farmers are different people — [14:38]​

Listen / watch: YouTube · Apple · Spotify​

One question for you

If someone asked you tomorrow what percentage of your company's profit comes from existing customers, would your CFO, your CRO, and your Head of CS give the same answer?

Andrew

If you love the podcast and haven't already, please consider leaving us a review and feedback!

Andrew Michael

Host of Churn FM, the podcast for subscription economy pros to learn how the world's fastest-growing companies are tackling churn and using retention to fuel their growth.

34 Kimonos, Apartment 102, Nicosia, 2006
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

CHURN FM

Churn.fm is the podcast for subscription economy pros to learn how the world's fastest-growing companies are tackling churn and using retention to fuel their growth. Each week we share the top tips and advice from our episodes in this newsletter.

Read more from CHURN FM

Episode #308 Watch now Building faster doesn’t fix the wrong assumptions. Hi Reader, Two executives are debating whether a customer would adopt an AI feature. One says compliance makes it impossible. The other disagrees. The marketing lead picks up her phone and texts the buyer. They get him on speakerphone. There are nuances in the regulation the team hadn’t understood. An entire strategy meeting, briefly interrupted by a customer. April Dunford shared this story when she returned to Churn...

Episode #307 Watch now Beyond the first sale: Winning customers back. Hi Reader, A customer leaves. You log the reason, update the forecast and move on. But what happens after that? In this week’s conversation, Emilia D’Anzica shared that one client recovered seven figures in the first year of its win-back programme. Emilia’s advice: understand why customers left, stay in touch and be honest about what has changed. A “we miss you” email has a lot of heavy lifting to do if the product still...

Episode #306 Watch now Beyond Retries: Why Payments Fail and How to Recover Them Hi Reader, How much of your churn from failed payments do you consider outside your control? At Hotjar, we saw a lot of failures from cross-border transactions. Processing locally and in the customer’s local currency improved the chances of those payments going through. The customer wanted to pay. How we collected the payment mattered. This week, I spoke with Jack Cregan, founder of Paymend, about what actually...