E300 | Building Retention into Your DNA: Matthew Tharp on Churn Signals, ICP & Cold Email


Sponsored by Vitally, the all-in-one Customer Success Platform.

Hi Reader,

Today on the show, we're joined by Matthew Tharp, CEO of Hunter.io and former VP of Worldwide Retention at LogMeIn, where he owned NRR across nine products and learned what separates companies that solve churn from those that struggle with it forever.

Matthew breaks down why retention must be built into your DNA from day one, how to spot churn signals in the first three weeks, and why the best cold outreach comes from smaller lists and shorter emails—not scale.

Here’s what you’ll take away from this episode:

🧬 Why Fixing Retention Late Almost Always Fails
📊 The 3-Week Usage Pattern That Predicts Churn
🎯 How to Choose Your ICP Based on Market Opportunity
📧 Why Email Lists Under 100 People Get 80%+ Better Replies

Tune in to the full episode on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast platform.

If you love the podcast and haven't already, please consider leaving us a review and feedback!


Vitally is the first platform designed for today’s CS team, allowing you to operate with unparalleled efficiency, improve NRR, deliver best-in-class customer experiences, and get more work done.
​

Even better? If you influence CS decisions at a B2B SaaS company with 50-1000 employees, Vitally is giving you a free pair of AirPods for taking a qualified demo with the team.

​
Interested in maximizing your team’s productivity, visibility, and collaboration?


​Andrew Michael​

Host of Churn FM, the podcast for subscription economy pros to learn how the world's fastest-growing companies are tackling churn and using retention to fuel their growth.

34 Kimonos, Apartment 102, Nicosia, 2006
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

CHURN FM

Churn.fm is the podcast for subscription economy pros to learn how the world's fastest-growing companies are tackling churn and using retention to fuel their growth. Each week we share the top tips and advice from our episodes in this newsletter.

Read more from CHURN FM

Episode #308 Watch now Building faster doesn’t fix the wrong assumptions. Hi Reader, Two executives are debating whether a customer would adopt an AI feature. One says compliance makes it impossible. The other disagrees. The marketing lead picks up her phone and texts the buyer. They get him on speakerphone. There are nuances in the regulation the team hadn’t understood. An entire strategy meeting, briefly interrupted by a customer. April Dunford shared this story when she returned to Churn...

Episode #307 Watch now Beyond the first sale: Winning customers back. Hi Reader, A customer leaves. You log the reason, update the forecast and move on. But what happens after that? In this week’s conversation, Emilia D’Anzica shared that one client recovered seven figures in the first year of its win-back programme. Emilia’s advice: understand why customers left, stay in touch and be honest about what has changed. A “we miss you” email has a lot of heavy lifting to do if the product still...

Episode #306 Watch now Beyond Retries: Why Payments Fail and How to Recover Them Hi Reader, How much of your churn from failed payments do you consider outside your control? At Hotjar, we saw a lot of failures from cross-border transactions. Processing locally and in the customer’s local currency improved the chances of those payments going through. The customer wanted to pay. How we collected the payment mattered. This week, I spoke with Jack Cregan, founder of Paymend, about what actually...